Lately in movies
making movie adaptations of Books didnt go so well for studios,
as in the vast majoriyt of book reader said it was not as good as the books or that the source matirial is far better, which created a fan war between book reader / source matirial hard core fans and the rest of the people you can see reviews for the new LOTR tv show, the little mermaid, the school of good and evil and the list goes on.
So i was sure this movie that is also based on an amazing book is going to divide the fans.
But i think somehow they managed to make a movie adaptation of the book that is Amazing ! And just as good as the book !
The movie shows the brutality of WW1, and stay in this prespective of the reader from the book
never give too much information and just shows the very hard reality the people expirienced .
This moie has great acting everyone here is doing an amazing job, it has very good Special Effects and it is right up there with one of the best war movies ever created.
The fact its not on the classic vietnam or ww2 patrern only gives it more points but this is also the book
the only very little comment i will say about this movie is that they are very true to the book sometimes.too much i believe like JRRT said, books are books and Movies are Movies and each one has its own magic they could have gone a bit more creative in the shooting , or the scenes build up, and i would love to see a bit.more practical effects as you can see there is a lot of Green Screen and special effects going but they are SO good that this is very little comment
the movie is great just what i had expected from it and can honestly say as a book reader this was just as good as the book !
as in the vast majoriyt of book reader said it was not as good as the books or that the source matirial is far better, which created a fan war between book reader / source matirial hard core fans and the rest of the people you can see reviews for the new LOTR tv show, the little mermaid, the school of good and evil and the list goes on.
So i was sure this movie that is also based on an amazing book is going to divide the fans.
But i think somehow they managed to make a movie adaptation of the book that is Amazing ! And just as good as the book !
The movie shows the brutality of WW1, and stay in this prespective of the reader from the book
never give too much information and just shows the very hard reality the people expirienced .
This moie has great acting everyone here is doing an amazing job, it has very good Special Effects and it is right up there with one of the best war movies ever created.
The fact its not on the classic vietnam or ww2 patrern only gives it more points but this is also the book
the only very little comment i will say about this movie is that they are very true to the book sometimes.too much i believe like JRRT said, books are books and Movies are Movies and each one has its own magic they could have gone a bit more creative in the shooting , or the scenes build up, and i would love to see a bit.more practical effects as you can see there is a lot of Green Screen and special effects going but they are SO good that this is very little comment
the movie is great just what i had expected from it and can honestly say as a book reader this was just as good as the book !
