I was surprised they sort of glossed over the crime and then started bending toward sympathy for the perp without yet broaching the fact that he had already been diagnosed with schizophrenia and had been using meth -- a known danger combo. In fact 20 minutes in, they still hadn't made it clear that he did the crime nor what the evidence was. But very shortly it does become clear that whether he committed the crime is not in question. The show opens up with the comment that one of the jurors asked is there a worst crime and if not we should give him the worst penalty. As someone in the legal field I disagree that's the way to determine the punishment. Yes, ill people can appear innocent to family and bleeding hearts but that just gives then more leeway to commit unforgivable acts. His caretakers were just as much at fault. That being said, he does not belong out in society because he's proven he will not stay on his meds, if nothing else. Guilty by reason of insanity is a misunderstood term, thanks to the media. It really is just a way to ensure the person receives treatment while incarcerated -- not with the goal of being cured and released. Adults with schizophrenia have the mental self control of a child without the usual sense of right and wrong. He should have already been in a facility and this would not have happened. But Death is a misunderstood penalty - it was first used to rid society of the murderer, not to deter others nor punish the convict. Will we ever be a society who wants to house and rehabilitate evil rather than rid ourselves of the threat? I doubt it. But some cases are not that black and white. If someone killed my child, I personally wouldn't want them to have the freedom of escaping their miserable life through death. Western society puts too much idolization on life and thinks of death as something horrifying. Really, we might be in hell right now. Many ancient societies view death as moving on, not some final act. But I digress. The presentation here is slow and there's a lot of talking by the family and experts etc that is hard to sit through. It feels like a film hoping to spotlight the idea that death penalty is wrong. Luckily, we all get to vote for officials per state and are not imprisoned by the screaming of bleeding hearts -- yet (Let's go Brandon).
Review of The Worst Crime
