New Year's Eve Nightmare
- Episode aired Dec 18, 2022
![Paula Zahn, Scott Watson, Eric S. Robertson, Kevin B. Mulligan, Raymond Brenkert, and Tom Scorzone in On the Case with Paula Zahn (2009)](https://m.media-amazon.com/images/M/MV5BODUxOWVmMTktYWNhNi00Yzk4LWJlNmEtZGQxODliNjJkY2E1XkEyXkFqcGdeQXVyMTA3MzQ4MTc0._V1_QL75_UX190_CR0,2,190,281_.jpg)
Pensacola, Florida: Shortly before 5:00 AM on January 1, 1985, Tonya Marie Ethridge McKinley, age 23, is found dead on the roadside. She is identified by the contents of her purse. Law enfor... Read allPensacola, Florida: Shortly before 5:00 AM on January 1, 1985, Tonya Marie Ethridge McKinley, age 23, is found dead on the roadside. She is identified by the contents of her purse. Law enforcement homicide detectives are unable to solve the case in 1985, but they have the foresig... Read allPensacola, Florida: Shortly before 5:00 AM on January 1, 1985, Tonya Marie Ethridge McKinley, age 23, is found dead on the roadside. She is identified by the contents of her purse. Law enforcement homicide detectives are unable to solve the case in 1985, but they have the foresight to collect biological evidence from the victim and from a bloody towel left at the scen... Read all