Leanne passes out while watching Sean, a chef, kill and prepare eels in the kitchen. Using the address from her application letter to Dorothy, Julian and a private investigator, Roscoe, go to Medicine Bridge, Wisconsin, to investigate Leanne. They discover a burned out house that belonged to the Grayson family, and graves for Leanne, who was born in 2001 and died in 2007, and her parents, Stephan and Laura, who also perished in the house fire. Julian believes Leanne is an imposter who is trying to get money from the family through blackmail. Leanne begins to emulate Dorothy.