Having only seen the first part of the mini series I'm drawn back from taking a side of: it's good or it's bad. However, there are some points that I would like to bring out.
What I do like: The special effects. The sandworms put the Dune movie to shame. I absolutely loved to watch the scenes with them. The ships no longer look like boxes.
What I dont like: The changes. "Tell me of the waters on your home world, Usul." That is the line. That is what the line should be. I don't like the change in calling him Usul. I'm certian in a 6 hour mini series they could explain the Fremen naming more. I don't like that Paul met Stilgar before the dessert exile. I also find it unfitting and out of place for him to meet Irulan prematurely. He never cared about her at all, she was just a vessel for him later. The scene with the hunter seeker lost it's meaning to me with it's additions. The lack of inner voice gives characters less convictions.
Most of all - they didn't wear their face masks on their still suits. And they left the doors open. Both of which are a no-no on Arrakis.
What I do like: The special effects. The sandworms put the Dune movie to shame. I absolutely loved to watch the scenes with them. The ships no longer look like boxes.
What I dont like: The changes. "Tell me of the waters on your home world, Usul." That is the line. That is what the line should be. I don't like the change in calling him Usul. I'm certian in a 6 hour mini series they could explain the Fremen naming more. I don't like that Paul met Stilgar before the dessert exile. I also find it unfitting and out of place for him to meet Irulan prematurely. He never cared about her at all, she was just a vessel for him later. The scene with the hunter seeker lost it's meaning to me with it's additions. The lack of inner voice gives characters less convictions.
Most of all - they didn't wear their face masks on their still suits. And they left the doors open. Both of which are a no-no on Arrakis.
Tell Your Friends