I'll summarize my thoughts in each era of the show:
Classic Era (Seasons 1-5, 1984-1998): 10/10, the peak of the show, best characters, sets, lore, storytelling, and music.
Gullane Era (Seasons 6-7, 2002-2003): 6/10, being post-Magic Railroad, it was a major step down. It's not bad, but it's not good either. There's inconsistency in the character, more simplistic sets, and formulaic storytelling.
HiT Era (Seasons 8-11, 2004-2007): 4/10, the story and characters become less interesting. It's also dumbed-down by these learning segments on PBS.
Side note: Season 12 is its own category. 0/10, the CGI faces and humans don't fit the model universe at all, and the episodes are worse than ever.
Nitrogen Era (Seasons 13-16, 2009-2012): 3/10, the switch to full CGI was NOT a smooth landing. The stories are all the exact same. A character has to collect something or do a random task, they mess up, then try to fix their mistake, then mess up two more times, then learn their lesson. It's not good.
Arc Era (Seasons 17-21, 2013-2017): 8/10, a phenomenal return to good storytelling after Mattel purchased the franchise. There are some episodes that aren't good, but this era has more good than bad.
BWBA Era (Seasons 22-24, 2018-2021): 0/10, factually killed the show. Awful storytelling, bad characters, and even the CGI got worse. Mattel went from saving the franchise to killing it.
Classic Era (Seasons 1-5, 1984-1998): 10/10, the peak of the show, best characters, sets, lore, storytelling, and music.
Gullane Era (Seasons 6-7, 2002-2003): 6/10, being post-Magic Railroad, it was a major step down. It's not bad, but it's not good either. There's inconsistency in the character, more simplistic sets, and formulaic storytelling.
HiT Era (Seasons 8-11, 2004-2007): 4/10, the story and characters become less interesting. It's also dumbed-down by these learning segments on PBS.
Side note: Season 12 is its own category. 0/10, the CGI faces and humans don't fit the model universe at all, and the episodes are worse than ever.
Nitrogen Era (Seasons 13-16, 2009-2012): 3/10, the switch to full CGI was NOT a smooth landing. The stories are all the exact same. A character has to collect something or do a random task, they mess up, then try to fix their mistake, then mess up two more times, then learn their lesson. It's not good.
Arc Era (Seasons 17-21, 2013-2017): 8/10, a phenomenal return to good storytelling after Mattel purchased the franchise. There are some episodes that aren't good, but this era has more good than bad.
BWBA Era (Seasons 22-24, 2018-2021): 0/10, factually killed the show. Awful storytelling, bad characters, and even the CGI got worse. Mattel went from saving the franchise to killing it.
Tell Your Friends