Reviews

47 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
UFOs & Aliens (1999 TV Movie)
8/10
Simple but scientific look at UFOs and Aliens
11 June 2009
I've just watched a DVD call "UFOs and Aliens" with Jeri Ryan as narrator (she played 7 of 9 in the Star Trek: Voyager TV show) and I'm assuming this IMDb entry is the same show (although the version I watched was dated 2003, but it could just be a re-edition of the 1999 US version. I don't know).

Anyway, this is a good basic show that probably won't make the pure sceptics or the hard-core believers happy because it takes the middle ground ('we can't prove or disprove UFO visitations').

It has 3 main chapters (about 50 mins each) that cover alien encounters, UFO technology, the search for aliens through the SETI program and other scientific theories such as interstellar time/space travel.

The part I found fascinating was the hypnotist called 'Kreskin the Amazing' who convinced a test group that they could see UFOs and aliens out in the garden! One poor woman suddenly 'remembered' being probed by an alien as a child in her bedroom and how she has seen them many times since and they have messages for her which she'll now consider writing a book about (the show implies she had no prior interest in aliens). This obvious example of the unreliability of human psychology and perception is balanced by alien abduction experts who state abductees tell such a consistent story that there must be something going on.

The Extras has a short summary on the US military investigations (Project Blue Book, etc) from the 1950s onward, where the military (yes, the actual military) came to the startling conclusion that they should cover-up genuine UFO encounters because it could lead to human society being subsumed by a superior alien culture (presumably because aliens would run the earth better than the US government!).

The Extras also includes some movie moments from "Encounter of the Third Kind", "The Day the Earth Stood Still", and "ET" to show how popular culture has shaped our ideas of aliens. I just hope real aliens haven't watched these movies because we tend to want to blow them up a lot.

I'd recommend this even if it does seem a bit cheesy and clunky (the animation is a bit dated). If you are a believer it won't convince you to stop, but if you are a total sceptic it might convince you to reconsider your view.

And it is not really scary or anything, so if aliens creep you out this is a good place to start to get a well-balanced primer.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
A nice film, but slow as a wet week
29 November 2008
Warning: Spoilers
A gently meandering film about two brothers growing up in Montana in the 1920s. They fly fish a lot.

At the one hour mark I thought something dramatic was about to happen (at last!) when the love interest's annoying brother blows in from Hollywood. Then at one hour 30 mins I thought something dramatic might happen (at last!) when the brothers visit a gambling den. Then at one hour 45 mins I though something surely dramatic is about to happen (at long #$% last!) when they go fishing.

When something actually dramatic does occur we don't see it but are told about it by the ever present sombre voice-over. Then the film ends.

This movie made me realise two things: (a) some books can't translate to screen and probably the attempt shouldn't even be made, and (b) movies based on old folks reminiscing about youth and loved-ones gone are really quite depressing, and I will avoid them in future.

A nice film for a spare Sunday afternoon.
7 out of 16 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Walk the Talk (2000)
9/10
Nice dark comedy
6 February 2007
Warning: Spoilers
This slightly dark comedy was wonderfully entertaining in an understated way. It reminded me of Little Miss Sunshine.

The plot seems straight forward, but it is anything but join the dots. A z-grade entrepreneur called Joey Grasso (Salvatore Coco) convinces his paraplegeic girlfriend Bonita (Sacha Horler) to lend him money to help aging has-been singer Nikki (Nikki Bennett) to become a recording star. Joey and Nikki first meet at a lame self-help group where she cries at a film about penguins (used as an example of following your dream no matter how many knock back you get, since penguins fall off icebergs all the time but just climb back up. I'd think the orcas would have something to do with it but I digress).

It all goes disastrously wrong for Joey, and Bonita and Nikki end up wishing they'd never had anything to do with him.

OK, there are some not so good bits. Bonita, the paraplegic girlfriend, is not well thought out - she is like three people: the Jesus lovin' churchgoer; the bitter girlfriend who hates God for making her chair-bound; and the doormat who keeps giving Joey money even though she knows she is more competent at PR than he is. Is Joey blind to his own incompetence or is he really a conman out to make a quick million using others? It is never clear, which also is a slight weakness.

The character of Nikki is a delight though. That's why I'm a bit extravagant and giving it a 9. OK, so I knew a woman just like her once - completely charmless narcissist who was going to be the next Whitney Houston but didn't seem to know, or care, that she was so rude to others that they ran a mile rather than hear her sing (like Nikki, she wasn't very good). I love movies about narcissists.

I was half-expecting the movie to end with Bonita becoming the next great church singer as a way to prove that Nikki might have done better without Joey's help, but it ends up somewhere else which was a pleasant surprise. But a movie that sends up self-help groups, evangelical churches, and RSL pension-Thursday with geriatric hip-grinding Casanova's singing 'Why Why Why Delilah', has gotta have something going for it.

It looks like a foreign (US or British) remake is on the cards (starring Carey Ewls) for 2006. Let's see how it compares.
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Criminal Minds: Secrets and Lies (2006)
Season 1, Episode 21
4/10
What's going on...
5 December 2006
Warning: Spoilers
This is one of the worst episodes because the script is trite and the leaps of logic large. I'd taped this and even replaying it I couldn't figure out what was going on in some scenes because the actors muttered too quickly. It was something about a CIA agent that Gideon had done a psychological review of being murdered and a family he was trying to hide from foreign interests disappearing. His murder is an inside job and the BAU team has to identify which CIA agent in the guy's team is the bad guy. Amazingly, even though they are working inside the CIA building they aren't bugged. Worse, two unbelievable scenes should've been scrapped altogether: Elle tries to strong arm a female CIA agent by nastily asking if she was sexually assaulted on a recent case, and when the agent doesn't respond Elle shouts at her. So much for the exceptional mental cool Gideon tells the team the CIA agents have at the beginning of the show. Elle's character just isn't consistent from one show to the next. The second unlikely scene is when another agent is shown a note Gideon wrote (we don't know what it says at that point) and told by Hotchner to consider his next words carefully (he's being offered a deal). Later, when we find out what the note said, this conversation (and the agent's response) doesn't make sense. If the note said what it said what was THAT scene all about? All over the shop to be honest.
6 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Monk: Mr. Monk Goes Back to School (2003)
Season 2, Episode 1
6/10
Monk at his soppiest
22 November 2006
Warning: Spoilers
Monk gets extra soppy as he goes back to his dead wife's alma mater to investigate the death of a teacher there. The police say suicide. Monk says murder. To solve the crime he decides to stay at school and teach the classes of the dead teacher. Yes, it IS a little far fetched, even for this show, to have Monk volunteer for such things given how phobic he is suppose to be. The schtick of what happens in class is predictable and drags on a little too long (and why do classes that have just started end in 5 mins?). But anyway, he solves it all, and gets the bad guy, as we know he will, and then he can be a little more soppy over Trudi's demise since she was so perfect (part of the plot that is getting a little on my nerves and I wished they'd downplay).
15 out of 39 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Monk: Mr. Monk and the Marathon Man (2002)
Season 1, Episode 8
7/10
Standard fare
22 November 2006
Warning: Spoilers
A woman is murdered and then thrown out of an apartment building. Her boyfriend has an airtight alibi - he was running a marathon at the time. Better yet, all competitors in the race have electronic devices that record their time when they pass sensors, and his shows he ran the whole race. How did he do it? It comes down to chamomile tea of all things. Meanwhile, Monk meets one of his sporting idols, a great runner from the 70s, (yes, we're suppose to believe he likes sports?!) and there is some heartwarming moments when said sporting great gives Monk some words of wisdom in the end. Very work-about, if a little formulaic and it becomes clear quickly how it was done even before Monk gives his usual summation.
6 out of 14 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Criminal Minds: Charm and Harm (2006)
Season 1, Episode 20
4/10
Dull episode
21 November 2006
Warning: Spoilers
The team have to track down a killer who drowns his victims - he's on the move and the killings are getting less organised and more random. The team split up with Elle and Morgan zipping around Carolina and Georgia by plane and car, while Gideon, Reid and Hotchner talk to the man's father and try to figure out what motivates him. Problem with this episode is the team have the killer's name at the start and their profile doesn't actually help them track him down. It is a waste of screen time to have Gideon trying to pin down why the killer drowns his victims. It just doesn't help in the end, and it comes down to just good ol' leg work. Elle and Morgan's road trip is just makes the whole thing feel rushed and chaotic. Not one of the best episodes by a long shot.
4 out of 16 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Monk: Mr. Monk Goes to the Circus (2003)
Season 2, Episode 4
7/10
A complicated way to kill someone...
20 November 2006
Warning: Spoilers
A hooded ninja-type figure shoots a circus guy at a café then wheels away. Stottlemeye brings in Monk who hates circuses, especially the clowns. Turns out that Sharona has a problem with elephants. Problem is that Monk's main suspect has a broken leg. It just gets silly from there on in. The episode is saved when Monk's hostility to Sharona's elephant phobia result in her going on strike (no wipes provided). Lots of amusing moments ensue. The final scene is amusing, although I wish they's explore the selfish side of Monk's personality more often, because he comes across as caring and sympathetic in other episodes when he solves cases, rather than smug when he catches the bad guy which is what I think the writers are aiming for (his 'release' when he puts everything in order as part of his OCD).
7 out of 12 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Monk: Mr. Monk and the Billionaire Mugger (2002)
Season 1, Episode 6
6/10
Is this Murder She Wrote?
20 November 2006
Warning: Spoilers
An adequate episode about a dating couple who are mugged outside a theatre but who fight back killing the mugger. Turns out the mugger is a famous billionaire. Monk is brought in to find out what on earth one of the richest men on the planet was doing trying to mug someone. Of course there is a twist, but it all plays too much like Murder She Wrote (not a bad show in itself but formulaic nonetheless). Work-about fare with a bit of silliness about a hired actor thrown in (I'm sure the cast loved making comments like 'he's quite an actor!', and 'look at him go, he's magnificent' or something close to that). It is actually Sharona who comes up with the pivotal clue, so at least the dynamic duo part of plot line is working well here. Otherwise, there are better episodes.
11 out of 25 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Monk: Mr. Monk and the Red-Headed Stranger (2002)
Season 1, Episode 11
7/10
Enjoyable episode
20 November 2006
Warning: Spoilers
I liked this episode, but mainly because of who the 'stranger' was. It is unlikely that Monk would be a country fan I think, but he plays the clarinet in this episode and I've got a soft spot for the clarinet. It is painful to watch him (Monk) attempt to play the instrument after someone else tongues the reed, but that is par for the course with this show. It's these elements that make it a show above the usual detective fare. But again, the person that is the suspect is obvious from the start, it's just left up to Monk to tell us how it was done. I give up on caring about the crimes but love to watch Monk and Sharona interact and think they are the best duo in a long, long time on television.
17 out of 22 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Monk: Mr. Monk and the Airplane (2002)
Season 1, Episode 12
7/10
I hate planes myself...
20 November 2006
Warning: Spoilers
Monk and Sharona go on a short plane trip to visit Sharona's aunt. Monk is phobic about air travel. Don't blame him. White knuckle moments abound, with annoying children, talkative seat neighbours and worries about the survivability of sitting in the seat (rather than other seats). Meanwhile Sharona is taken with a celebrity sitting in first class. Oh, and meanwhile, of course, a passenger is a murderer who killed off his wife and someone else is murdered mid-flight. No one notices except Monk. It all comes down to a few clues that only he notices. Honestly, you'd think every second person was a mass murderer. Forget the murder mystery, just appreciate the bad plane ride, and how Monk reduces the stewardess to drink.
13 out of 21 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Monk: Mr. Monk and the Earthquake (2002)
Season 1, Episode 10
6/10
Average episode
20 November 2006
Warning: Spoilers
This has the Australian actor Cameron Dado in it - one of the famous Dado brothers (Andrew is one but I forget the other ones name) - who plays the villain. He's a looker and his acting is pretty good, but the script is so predictable. The problem with this episode is that the exact timing of the crime and the follow up crimes is too unbelievable, but I do like the interaction between Gail (Sharona's sister) and Monk (who Gail clearly has a problem with). I did wonder how Gail had such a hot pad given her personality (it looked like the decor was out of a ritzy apartment interior design mag) but otherwise I have no problem with the characters. It is the banal murder crimes that remind me too much of Murder She Wrote.
12 out of 33 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Monk: Mr. Monk Takes a Vacation (2002)
Season 1, Episode 9
7/10
A bit silly but fun
20 November 2006
Warning: Spoilers
The crime itself is a bit dumb (the murder, first seen by Benji - Sharona's son - turns into a hunt for the body, which seems to be moved around a lot) but the whole idea of Monk not being able to relax at a beach resort is cute. His involvement with the hotel security chief, whose only training seems to be from film noir movies is amusing enough, especially once she uses a gadget that shows up human bodily fluids (blood, mucus and semen as she explains until Monk tells her to stop) that the naked eye can't detect. She uses Monk's hotel room as a test and he, of course, goes into germ phobic meltdown. The concluding moments are nice as Monk resolves the case - but unbelievable - but this show isn't about reality.
18 out of 26 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Monk: Mr. Monk Goes to the Asylum (2002)
Season 1, Episode 5
6/10
A bit dumb
20 November 2006
Warning: Spoilers
OK - not the best episode. Mr Monk is arrested after walking into someone else's home (thinking it is his own) and it is clear he is having a bad day. While in the nut house for a few days 'rest' he gets involved in the mysterious death of a doctor from several years earlier. And guess what! He solves it - after some business involving Santa Claus and a very angry woman (both patients of the said nut house).This episode shows that anything mentioned earlier always has a bearing on the outcome, so it is pretty much waiting for the flagged objects to turn up later. The crime solved there isn't much mention of his breakdown or whether it will appear again. How mentally ill is the guy? It seems to ebb and flow.
12 out of 27 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Monk: Mr. Monk Goes to the Carnival (2002)
Season 1, Episode 4
7/10
One of the best episodes
20 November 2006
Warning: Spoilers
Forget about the crime, and especially its resolution, because the best bit about this episode is Monk's interview by the review panel to get reinstated as a police officer, and Stottlemeyer's revelation about his support for it. The scene when they meet in the corridor is superb. It is pathetic to watch Monk's reaction, after he gets his hopes up so high and it gives an indication of how far he has come from his breakdown that he thinks he has a hope of working as a police office again, and how others don't see him as competent. Meanwhile Stottlmeyer wants him to solve a murder that implicates an officer with a bad history of beating suspects. The case is the usual stuff (not much physical proof but hoping the bad guy confesses) but still classic stuff.
17 out of 20 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Monk: Mr. Monk Meets Dale the Whale (2002)
Season 1, Episode 3
8/10
Some great moments but...
20 November 2006
Warning: Spoilers
Some great Monk moments where you can see that Adrian Monk hates Dale the Whale (a bed ridden obese man who is a master criminal), because he thinks Dale was responsible for killing his wife. Meanwhile, Monk has to figure out how Dale killed a judge who identified Dale by telephone moments before she was bludgeoned to death. How the crime was done was predictable but there is some business with Sharona getting work with Dale that was unlikely - why would Dale do it knowing she is Monk's assistant? But still, the tension created by Monk's reaction to Dale's taunting about Trudy's death (Monk wife) is priceless. And the last two scenes are rewind moments.
10 out of 14 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Monk: Mr. Monk and the Psychic (2002)
Season 1, Episode 2
8/10
Quirky as expected
15 November 2006
Warning: Spoilers
A woman disappears but is soon found by a psychic who claims she found the woman's body through her special gift. Monk doesn't believe in psychic powers and soon suspects it is murder but must convince everyone else, especially Sharona who thinks the psychic is the real deal and wants a lovelife reading.

Monk's techniques are very similar to the sort of stuff in the original Sherlock Holmes stories (blisters on an finger in one later episode leads him to conclude a man has been on a fishing trip), but often the murder case takes a back seat to an exploration of Monk's OCD and the tragi-comedic situations it leads to.

This episode has some amusing and lovely interactions between him and his nurse, Sharona, and lifts the whole thing above the usual detective fare on TV. The endings is a little implausible, and no-one seems to actually feel anything for the dead person, but this is a quirky show rather than a drama.
16 out of 22 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Criminal Minds: Machismo (2006)
Season 1, Episode 19
6/10
Something a bit different, but the same
15 November 2006
Warning: Spoilers
The team goes to Mexico to hunt down a possible serial killer who targets senior women. They have to contend with poor police resources and a bigwig who doesn't want to acknowledge it is a serial killer because it will scare off the tourists.

Going to Mexico and actually having conversations with the locals in their native tongue is a bit of a change, and revealing significant cultural attitudes adds a twist, but in the end it took the team and the local police ages to discover the clue that leads them to the killer. They had it before their eyes but they could not see! Elle's character plays a large role in this one (because she can speak Spanish fluently) but I find her so cold that I don't understand why the writers insist she be portrayed as the sympathetic female character left to interview female victims and the like. It just doesn't work. Gideon plays such a large role in the beginning of the show and then disappears near the end, and there is some family stuff concerning Hotchner but then he takes a back seat role. Just too many cooks in this show - they need to drop a couple of major characters.

I'm beginning to think Australian TV is cutting 5 minutes off this show - it doesn't run a full hour here, but 55 mins (with ads). This could account for some of the clunky plot lines if true.
4 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Criminal Minds: Somebody's Watching (2006)
Season 1, Episode 18
5/10
Standard fare
15 November 2006
Warning: Spoilers
People in show biz are getting knocked off, and it becomes clear very quickly that they are connected to a young starlet in some way. Reid is given the task to bodyguard the actress, who turns out to be a bit of a predator herself, making for some monkey business in the pool.

An OK episode, although there are some clunky scenes particularly the first scene in the art gallery when Gideon acts a little strangely - I didn't quite get the point. May be he just didn't like LA, I couldn't tell. But by the end it becomes a bit of a yawn. And I got confused with so many young blonde actresses - they couldn't have thrown in a few brunettes or redheads so I could keep straight who was who?
3 out of 18 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Gentle exploration of Christian Fundamentalists
12 November 2006
For non-Americans the US Christian Fundamentalists movement (or whatever they call themselves because I think some of them don't like being called fundamentalists) is a fascinating thing to behold. Sort of like visiting an unfamiliar and weird country and being glad you don't live there, but also glad you went.

Andrew Denton is famous in Australia for his interview shows (such as the Money or the Gun, and his current Enough Rope). He is one of the best interviewers I've seen because he gets his guests to talk about the intimate details of their lives, including their flaws, in great depth. He is like a father confessor.

He also has a real knack in letting people explain themselves without judgement. His non-emotive questioning is the trick and he uses it well in this documentary. I already knew a bit about the evangelical movement (although the Rapture was not something I'd heard of until a few years ago) but it is the wonderful explanations that he gets from convention stall holders themselves that is the real treat. The Jews promoting Israel to the Christians (so they can visit where Jesus walked) is amusing, and the European guy trying to be diplomatic about the singularly American Christian beliefs was so amusing it kept a smile on my face well after leaving. Just make sure you sit through the credits to see more footage and a joke from Denton.

A gentle documentary more suited for TV, but well worth wasting an hour and a half on.
12 out of 13 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Criminal Minds: A Real Rain (2006)
Season 1, Episode 17
7/10
Fast paced but they miss some clues
10 November 2006
Warning: Spoilers
The team is off to New York to find a vigilante killer who seems to be killing random victims, but their connection soon becomes clear. The team misses at least one obvious clue (and I can't believe they didn't have information on the murder weapon before the fourth victim!) early on - but I suppose solving the case in half an hour wouldn't make much of a show, now would it?

There is some really nice 'personal' stuff between the group especially when they go to a Chinese restaurant for dinner. There is talk of a previous case Gideon and Hotchner worked on that turned out badly and it gives an indication of how they deal with the legal system when it lets them down. This is echoed in the conclusion to this case, which confused me a little - what were the writers trying to imply? It isn't clear even with the last words from the newscast. And it isn't clear whether Gideon is upset or not with the outcome. May be the writers are being vague on purpose, but sometimes it just comes out as sloppy.

Elle's attitude to the job is beginning to grate. She points out over dinner that they only ever talk about cases even when having a nice dinner in New York, and last episode she asked Hotchner if it was strange that they were all available at short notice on a Saturday night to hunt a killer. No-one else does. Hasn't she been told this is a 24/7 job?

Still, an entertaining episode.
9 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Criminal Minds: The Tribe (2006)
Season 1, Episode 16
7/10
Good episode even with the spiritualism
7 November 2006
Warning: Spoilers
The team are off to investigate the murders of five young people who have been tortured to death at a controversial housing development site. There first suspect is a native American activist who is the policeman at the neighbouring Apache reservation. He ends up helping the team, while targeting his hostility for the FBI at Hotchner, as they track down who is using Indian warrior rites to kill off various groups of people. After a few of the 'usual suspects' are caught and questioned the killers are caught and brought to justice.

An interesting enough case, but an odd tone to the show compared to previous episodes. The last show had members of the BAU clearly affected by photos of the dried out bodies of long dead victims (which we are shown too) but there is hardly a quivering nostril at the descriptions or photos (which we don't see) of skinned alive or impaled people (including children). Gideon takes a back seat with no explanation, unusual given other shows he is the central character, but it does give Hotchner more to do, especially with his hostile activist 'friend' pointing out how Captain America he is. And it jarred to me that there was not on reference to the media or a journalist in sight given the severity and types of murders. But I suppose they just ran out of time to fit it all in.
7 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Criminal Minds: Unfinished Business (2006)
Season 1, Episode 15
7/10
Good episode but hair problems!
1 November 2006
Warning: Spoilers
A retired profiler has just released a book about the one who got away nearly 20 years earlier, when, Lo and Behold, the serial killer leaves a note at one of his book chats, and later leaves a fresh victim, to show he's back. Gideon, who just happens to be present at his old friend's seminar, gets in the BAU team to track the killer down.

A good episode with the emphasis on main character interactions. Gideon has to smooth the waters as his old friend, Max Ryan, drives the younger team members nuts with his snarkiness. OK, it's strange that they take the hardest road to track the serial killer (with Reid's super-human code breaking and Garcia's super-sonic computer hacking ability do we really need the other team members at all?) and I suspect just a full investigation of the first suspect's past would have lead them to the real killer, but it is quite suspenseful. It shows how important it is for investigators to distance themselves emotionally from the crimes or they could end up like Ryan - an obsessed and bitter old man.

There are more than the usual continuity problems of the type where actor's arms change pose when a different camera angle is used, but the really strange one is Elle's hair. Not since Babylon 5 (where the blonde psicorp cop's blunt-fringed short do changes next scene to the usual one length side-parted bob) has a female hairstyle changed mid-show, with no explanation, and backwards! At the start Elle sports a new badly cut puffy fringe, but it then morphs back to her usual one length side-parted shoulder length do. An experiment that went wrong that the show's hairstylists successfully hid in later scenes? A mid-show taping hair cut before earlier scenes were shot? Or is it code for...something? Elle certainly seems less than cool this episode (she's really cranky at having to work a weekend and lets Hotchner know it twice). It's not important, I suppose, but it is odd.
5 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Criminal Minds: Riding the Lightning (2006)
Season 1, Episode 14
2/10
Morally repugnant episode
30 October 2006
Warning: Spoilers
Well filmed episode with great external and internal sequences, especially of the death watch prison cells. The actors who play husband and wife serial killers about to be executed are gritty enough to add some realism (especially with shaven heads!).

Where this episode falls down is the logical leaps that make Gideon and the team decide that the wife may be innocent of the murders, including that of her son. For profilers they don't seem to have done their homework particularly well (especially for such a famous case). There are no clues as such, but the leaps of logic Reid and Gideon make are tenuous and outright laughable. And Garcia's rapid computer tracking magic is way too unbelievable (can she really read THAT fast?).

The decision Gideon makes in the end is morally repugnant, and I don't know why it seems acceptable to the rest of the BAU team who've also come to the same conclusion about the wife. Does he have a right to make a decision on their behalf, or that of the State? What if one of the team is anti-death penalty? It is just too dumb and undermines the character of Gideon who in other episodes has been portrayed by a smart and morally staunch man who has no time for killers or their supporters, and can't be manipulated. It's just dumb that it didn't cross his mind that she may have a Martyr complex so wasn't able to make a sound decision for herself (the 'supporters' outside the prison who dress like the Jacob's victims - the husband killer - should've been a clue). Even if the woman is a saint, he has proved himself to have failed the Law he is suppose to uphold, no matter how sorry he felt for her.

Pity, because it could have been a gripping episode if a bit more logic and thought had gone into the story.
21 out of 109 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Criminal Minds: Poison (2006)
Season 1, Episode 13
5/10
Good concept but fails to hit the mark
25 October 2006
Warning: Spoilers
A bunch of people get poisoned with drugs that make them hullicinate while losing their memory. The team have to track down where and how the many victims got drugged so they can get a better idea of what category of poisoner they are dealing with, and hope to catch him before he strikes again.

The opening is very good (the hallucination someone has of 'scarey people' reminded me of a nightmare I once had) but then the episode gets messy as the team splits up to follow different leads. There is one terribly clunky scene (Elle arresting a suspect) which was so unconvincing that it jarred.

Only when I watched it a second time did I discover some facts that were mentioned in passing that were very important to the link of clues the team uses to solve the case. This episode also lacked the banter between the main characters which is the enjoyable part of this show.

OK, but it could've been better.

But I did like the motivation of the poisoner. Very real-life and believable.
2 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
An error has occured. Please try again.

Recently Viewed

 
\n \n \n\n\n