I really want to give this show a higher rating but I just can't. Cranston is acting with his hands tied behind his back and too many characters were severely miscast. But reading reviews that say much of this series is unrealistic makes me feel I should focus my review on why it's actually very realistic.
Some reviews devote their entire low stars to misunderstanding the show. For starters, the Judge is not a good guy before this all goes down - he and the Mayor are paid off by Desire to keep their people out of prison, including people like Eugene's mom who Desiato goes out of his way for to find some reason to dismiss her charges. If you misunderstood what was happening there, you are likely going to be lost through much of the series.
Reviewers complain that the show is full of race-baiting and claim that cops and lawyers are simply not like this.
It's set in N'Orlins where not only are police known to be corrupt but are considered to have no concern for the poor, predominantly black areas. They didn't collect evidence from the scene because they have no interest in what really happened -- for 3 reasons: they can never get people in that area to snitch about each other; it's a dangerous area even for cops; and it's owned by dirty cops who use the inhabitants in various ways including confidential informants or framing someone. The neighbors are see no; hear no; speak no people and that's why no one came out after the accident. Also, a white kid in that area truly would find himself surrounded by gang members very quickly. His mom having been there was different cuz she was a cop unknowingly in the company of corrupt cops who owned the neighborhood.
So, unfortunately, much of this film can only be understood by knowing these realities which are only very subtlety exposed.
There are other parts that are less realistic or dramatized, but the lawyer risking everything to "save" the little killer Eugene is very in line with today's liberal mentality of perceiving even the most dangerous thugs as victims of the system who would not be sociopaths if not for their circumstances.
Koffi was a great character - I wish they kept that actor and got rid of Eugene who was not as interesting. His willingness to go to prison for something he didn't do is a real thing. The deep fear and loyalty within the Desire gang was not well presented in Your honor. When Trey tells Chris Mo needs to go, it's Mo setting up Chris to test his loyalty after promising Trey a way back into the gang - his loyalty is to the leader, Mo, who has provided for him and makes lavish promises mostly unseen in this quasi presentation. Gangs are made up of fiercely loyal members who are recruited at very young ages from broken families where their needs are not being met. They are clothed, fed, provided with expensive toys and money, given attention and compliments - but also severely punished for small things. It's called Grooming. The series expects the audience to already be aware of these realities.
Some is dramatized and yet the series also holds back - a lot - in showing details to get us to the threshold of what it does choose to present.
Mo is not believable as a gang leader and the misfortune of making her love jones a lesbian causes the powerful pull of her obsession - her Achilles heel - to be lost on most the audience. Also, the idea that the singer wasn't accepting of the gang life was out of character or that Mo simply let her walk away.
My 5*, which is one more than I really want to give, is because the story is not really that unique and promises more than it delivers. Adam was well-played but most reviews don't understand the character - he's not trying to save his father or himself but rather he's reacting to the numbness his dad forces him into and then trying to understand his damages by getting close to the victim's sister. From there, things get out of his control.
Someone asked how Fia could have not known what Michael went to prison for, but the judge didn't go to prison for what he actually did; he went for made up charges that are never fully disclosed except for the suggestion to charge him for tax evasion.
I thought Lee was well-played but I noticed only a few people realized that her actions to save Eugene were immoral if not illegal and that it really speaks about the upside-down system we see right now. And speaking of -- yes, Judges do control the courtroom and the jury; just look at what they did in NY in June for counts the Supreme court declined to prosecute over 2 years earlier. I'm not saying I'm for it or against it, but you'd be blind not to know it happened.
I agree the title Your Honor seems a strange name since most of the show is not about Desiato being in the judges seat but the series of unfortunate events is because of actions he took as a judge. In that sense. I see why the series has this title.
Thanks for reading, hope I cleared some things up.
Some reviews devote their entire low stars to misunderstanding the show. For starters, the Judge is not a good guy before this all goes down - he and the Mayor are paid off by Desire to keep their people out of prison, including people like Eugene's mom who Desiato goes out of his way for to find some reason to dismiss her charges. If you misunderstood what was happening there, you are likely going to be lost through much of the series.
Reviewers complain that the show is full of race-baiting and claim that cops and lawyers are simply not like this.
It's set in N'Orlins where not only are police known to be corrupt but are considered to have no concern for the poor, predominantly black areas. They didn't collect evidence from the scene because they have no interest in what really happened -- for 3 reasons: they can never get people in that area to snitch about each other; it's a dangerous area even for cops; and it's owned by dirty cops who use the inhabitants in various ways including confidential informants or framing someone. The neighbors are see no; hear no; speak no people and that's why no one came out after the accident. Also, a white kid in that area truly would find himself surrounded by gang members very quickly. His mom having been there was different cuz she was a cop unknowingly in the company of corrupt cops who owned the neighborhood.
So, unfortunately, much of this film can only be understood by knowing these realities which are only very subtlety exposed.
There are other parts that are less realistic or dramatized, but the lawyer risking everything to "save" the little killer Eugene is very in line with today's liberal mentality of perceiving even the most dangerous thugs as victims of the system who would not be sociopaths if not for their circumstances.
Koffi was a great character - I wish they kept that actor and got rid of Eugene who was not as interesting. His willingness to go to prison for something he didn't do is a real thing. The deep fear and loyalty within the Desire gang was not well presented in Your honor. When Trey tells Chris Mo needs to go, it's Mo setting up Chris to test his loyalty after promising Trey a way back into the gang - his loyalty is to the leader, Mo, who has provided for him and makes lavish promises mostly unseen in this quasi presentation. Gangs are made up of fiercely loyal members who are recruited at very young ages from broken families where their needs are not being met. They are clothed, fed, provided with expensive toys and money, given attention and compliments - but also severely punished for small things. It's called Grooming. The series expects the audience to already be aware of these realities.
Some is dramatized and yet the series also holds back - a lot - in showing details to get us to the threshold of what it does choose to present.
Mo is not believable as a gang leader and the misfortune of making her love jones a lesbian causes the powerful pull of her obsession - her Achilles heel - to be lost on most the audience. Also, the idea that the singer wasn't accepting of the gang life was out of character or that Mo simply let her walk away.
My 5*, which is one more than I really want to give, is because the story is not really that unique and promises more than it delivers. Adam was well-played but most reviews don't understand the character - he's not trying to save his father or himself but rather he's reacting to the numbness his dad forces him into and then trying to understand his damages by getting close to the victim's sister. From there, things get out of his control.
Someone asked how Fia could have not known what Michael went to prison for, but the judge didn't go to prison for what he actually did; he went for made up charges that are never fully disclosed except for the suggestion to charge him for tax evasion.
I thought Lee was well-played but I noticed only a few people realized that her actions to save Eugene were immoral if not illegal and that it really speaks about the upside-down system we see right now. And speaking of -- yes, Judges do control the courtroom and the jury; just look at what they did in NY in June for counts the Supreme court declined to prosecute over 2 years earlier. I'm not saying I'm for it or against it, but you'd be blind not to know it happened.
I agree the title Your Honor seems a strange name since most of the show is not about Desiato being in the judges seat but the series of unfortunate events is because of actions he took as a judge. In that sense. I see why the series has this title.
Thanks for reading, hope I cleared some things up.
Tell Your Friends