I must admit, I had high expectations before watching this movie. I heard tons of positive reviews, and as a Miyazaki movie, I expected it to be poetic, deeply touching and rather sad. It seems numerous people felt that way when they saw it: it didn't work on me the tiniest bit.
What I liked: -the depiction of Japan in a modernization and westernization phase, something we rarely see on TV. Traditional kimonos side with western costumes, modern cars move along ancient ox carriages. The way this modernization impacts on the people could have been deepened though, even if it's not central to the movie
-the depiction of the work of engineers, the many little details that they have to take into account and that inspire them: the weight of screws, the form of a fish bone. This is also something rarely seen on TV that I for myself find quite fascinating.
-the beautiful landscapes and colors you expect of a Miyazaki moving. Since it shows the real world you may not be "spirited away", but still I found it very pretty.
What I didn't not enjoy: pretty much everything else. - First of all: "The wind rises" is veeeeery repetitive. I couldn't count the amount of train rides, plane crashes, dream flights with Caproni, unsubtle hints on the movie's maxim (Paul Valéry citation "Le vent se lève", wind blows in the face of the hero), and repetitions of this quite pretty melody that becomes extremely annoying the tenth time it is repeated (seriously, almost all of the film had one and the SAME melody).
- The story arc: in my opinion there was none. No suspense, no tension, the movie is just a 2 hours-long sequence of unrelated scenes glued to each other in a chronological manner. No character or relationship development either, and even some plot holes. I like slow paced movies where few happens (Sofia Coppola is one of my favorite director), but they have to be hypnotic, they shouldn't give you this feeling of waiting (which gives you the opportunity to ponder upon the reason why you keep watching). I waited during the whole movie to feel implicated, but nope, I was just bored beyond belief.
-This is mainly due to the characters and their relationships to each other, that feel extremely superficial and clichéd. Jiro is the good, studious and naive boy (with a few "knight in a white armor"-scenes), Naoko is shy, fragile and soooo in love, Kayo the little sister is a grumpy-faced Chihiro, the few Germans are cold and harsh control-freaks. That over the 20 years of the story none of the faces evolve doesn't help. The romance between perfect workaholic Jiro and his devoted (submissive?) wife that hasn't any background story and any wish of her own (except to die without disturbing her husband?!!) is also really disturbing and syrupy sweet, but let's skip this part.
-the main reason why I didn't like is the light and very oblique way it spoke about Japanese history, WW2 and the role of our nice hero Jiro. Jiro and his team conceived the Mitsubishi Zero, one of the deadliest plane of WW2, that was assembled by Korean and Chinese slaves? Let's not lose ONE SINGLE WORD about it. After all, poor Jiro didn't see one of his beloved planes come back from war. After all, Jiro has one or two naive pacifist punchlines: "I just wanted to build beautiful planes" "the weight of the plane will fit if we leave out the machine guns". Should be enough to excuse what he'd done for fascism in Japan. Which isn't acknowledged, either. The only suffering you see or hear of is that of the poor Japanese people (Tokyo earthquake, ruins after Americans bombed the country...), not the one Japan brought upon the whole Pacific. It could have been a nice tale about the impact of naive geniuses on the world, but it's not. Just feels like avoidance.
To me, Miyazaki gets none of it: the seriousness, the madness and the cruelty of that era of history. This film is ill-conceived and unreflected, and I'm still amazed by its critical acclaim. Definitely not a movie I'll recommend, except in a reflection upon whitewashing and Japan's blinkered examination of its own history.
15 out of 31 found this helpful.
Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Tell Your Friends