The series is visually stunning, with panoramic views, impressive action scenes (though there are too few of them) and CGI effects. The production values earned the 5 stars I've awarded.
The rendering of the literary masterpiece (the original three Foundation novels) into film is where this series fails. To say that the series is based on the novels is a stretch. The character names are certainly there, as are institutions like The Foundation and Empire. But the departure from the source material means that the series is based on the ideas of Isaac Asimov. This may not be a problem for those who haven't read the books, but for those of us who have, we wanted to see what's in the books on the screen.
I also recommend a shout out to Kim Stanley Robinson, author of the Mars Trilogy. A major scene came from Robinson's Red Mars, and is nowhere to be found in Asimov's work.
The rendering of the literary masterpiece (the original three Foundation novels) into film is where this series fails. To say that the series is based on the novels is a stretch. The character names are certainly there, as are institutions like The Foundation and Empire. But the departure from the source material means that the series is based on the ideas of Isaac Asimov. This may not be a problem for those who haven't read the books, but for those of us who have, we wanted to see what's in the books on the screen.
I also recommend a shout out to Kim Stanley Robinson, author of the Mars Trilogy. A major scene came from Robinson's Red Mars, and is nowhere to be found in Asimov's work.
Tell Your Friends